Published November 2026
Guest blog: Lucy Laidlaw - The midnight scroll: when is the right time to post about wellbeing?
Go BackThere is a certain irony in managing the social media channels for a wellbeing charity. We spend a lot of time encouraging people to look after themselves, get enough sleep, take a break and find a healthy balance in their lives. Yet, behind the scenes, I am looking at data that tells me the best time to reach our audience is getting later and later into the evening.
And it has left me with a bit of a dilemma.
Alongside my work with Farmstrong Scotland, I run a marketing and communications consultancy, working predominantly with rural businesses and organisations. Like most people responsible for managing social media, I spend a fair amount of time looking at analytics. What content works? What gets people talking? When are our followers online? And, perhaps most importantly, when should we publish content to give it the best chance of being seen?
The conventional advice is fairly straightforward. Post when your audience is online.
But what happens when your audience is online at a time when, arguably, they would be better off asleep?
Our audience is staying up later.
Over recent months, I've noticed a trend across the social media accounts I manage for clients, most of whom operate in the rural sector. The times when audiences are most active seem to be getting later and later.
For Farmstrong Scotland, Facebook is suggesting that we publish content after 9pm to get the best engagement.
TikTok is even more surprising. Our Farmstrong audience is most active between midnight and 1am.
Midnight!
Now, as a 42-year-old woman with two children, I can assure you there is very little on this earth that could persuade me to be awake at midnight on a school night, certainly not TikTok!
Of course, farming and crofting don't exactly follow a nine-to-five routine. There are early starts, late finishes, lambing and calving seasons and plenty of reasons why someone might legitimately be awake at unusual hours.
But I do wonder how many of us are awake because we need to be, and how many have simply fallen down the rabbit hole of one more video.
I certainly know how easy it is. I pick up my phone for a quick look and suddenly half an hour has disappeared. Or worse, an hour.
We know sleep matters
At Farmstrong Scotland, we talk a lot about looking after our physical and mental wellbeing, and getting a good night's sleep is part of that.
In an episode of our Blether Together podcast, Alyson O'Brien, Head of Sleep Action, shared practical advice about improving sleep, including the benefits of a good bedtime routine and recognising habits that might be keeping us awake.
You can read more in A Better Way to Hit the Hay: Sleep Tips from Alyson O'Brien.
The irony is that I could share that very article on TikTok at midnight and, according to our analytics, it might reach more people than if I shared it at lunchtime.
But would that really be the right thing to do?
When engagement and wellbeing don't quite align
For Farmstrong Scotland, social media is about getting practical advice, useful resources and real stories in front of farmers, crofters and everyone connected with agriculture.
Sometimes a post might be exactly what someone needs to read.
But there is a difference between reaching people and encouraging habits that might not be good for them.
We are already seeing a growing market for technology designed to help us spend less time on our phones. Apps that block social media, devices that lock phones away and settings that limit how long we can spend scrolling.
It seems rather extraordinary that we now need technology to protect us from other technology.
In marketing, it's easy to get caught up in the numbers. Reach, impressions, engagement rates, views and shares. They all have their place, but Farmstrong Scotland's ultimate aim isn't to keep people on social media for longer.
Quite the opposite, really.
So what should we do?
I haven't entirely settled the argument in my own head.
There is a perfectly reasonable case for publishing content when people are most likely to see it. After all, if someone is awake and scrolling, perhaps a Farmstrong post about sleep, wellbeing or taking time for yourself is a better thing to encounter than another endless stream of videos.
But I also think we have a responsibility to consider the behaviours we might inadvertently encourage.
For now, I'm inclined to favour publishing our content at more sociable hours, rather than chasing the very latest engagement peaks.
That doesn't mean ignoring the data. It means looking beyond it and remembering why we are creating the content in the first place.
And perhaps accepting that the most successful Farmstrong Scotland post isn't necessarily the one that keeps someone watching.
It might be the one that encourages them to put their phone down.
I'd be interested to hear what others think…
In the meantime, if you're reading this in bed at midnight, perhaps take it as a gentle nudge to put the phone down and get some sleep!